Abdul El-Sayed stands by criticism of fireworks, tells Americans to find other ways to ‘show your love’

Progressive policy ambitions meet practical realities as Americans weigh costs and consequences.

Source: New York Post
1 min read
Why This Matters

Abdul El-Sayed had a chance to walk back his fireworks gripe and instead he leaned into it. On "The Breakfast Club" he told Americans to find other ways to "show your love" for the country than shooting bottle rockets off in the backyard. This is a Senate candidate in Michigan, a state with a serious fireworks industry and a lot of regular folks who spend every July 4th doing exactly what he's now telling them not to do.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Abdul El-Sayed stands by criticism of fireworks, tells Americans to find other ways to ‘show your love’
Image via New York Post

Democratic Michigan U.S. Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed appeared to defend his criticism of Fourth of July fireworks on "The Breakfast Club" radio show.

Original source:

Read at New York Post

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Abdul El-Sayed had a chance to walk back his fireworks gripe and instead he leaned into it. On "The Breakfast Club" he told Americans to find other ways to "show your love" for the country than shooting bottle rockets off in the backyard. This is a Senate candidate in Michigan, a state with a serious fireworks industry and a lot of regular folks who spend every July 4th doing exactly what he's now telling them not to do.

The thing is, nobody made him relitigate this. He could have said "look, I was talking about noise complaints near hospitals" and moved on. Instead he doubled down with a lecture about better ways to love your country. That's the tell. It's not really about fireworks. It's about a candidate who can't help correcting people's patriotism even when the smart political move is to shut up and let it go.

Fireworks on the Fourth are corny, loud, occasionally someone loses a finger, and Americans have been doing it since before there was a United States to celebrate. Telling people there's a more enlightened way to mark independence is the kind of thing that sounds fine in a seminar room and terrible coming out of a candidate's mouth on drive-time radio. Voters don't need a senator to teach them how to feel about their own country.

If El-Sayed wants to run on infrastructure or prescription drug prices, fine, that's a real campaign. Running on "your fireworks are the wrong kind of love" is just handing his opponents a clip that plays itself.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.