David Hogg Got Leveled With a Brutal Community Note Regarding AI Data Centers

Progressive policy ambitions meet practical realities as Americans weigh costs and consequences.

Source: Townhall
1 min read
Why This Matters

David Hogg wants data centers built in Beverly Hills before they touch a working-class zip code, and on its face that sounds like a fine populist gut-punch. Except the whole pitch fell apart the moment somebody with actual expertise showed up in his replies. Community Notes exist for exactly this: not to silence him, just to add the context he skipped.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

David Hogg Got Leveled With a Brutal Community Note Regarding AI Data Centers
Image via Townhall

David Hogg, a left-wing political activist and former vice chairman of the Democratic National Committee, was brutally leveled by a Community Note last week after arguing that data centers should be built in America’s wealthiest neighborhoods before anywhere else.

Original source:

Read at Townhall

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

David Hogg wants data centers built in Beverly Hills before they touch a working-class zip code, and on its face that sounds like a fine populist gut-punch. Except the whole pitch fell apart the moment somebody with actual expertise showed up in his replies. Community Notes exist for exactly this: not to silence him, just to add the context he skipped. Turns out siting decisions for massive power-hungry server farms come down to things like transmission capacity, water access, and zoning, not a checklist of which neighborhoods have the nicest lawns.

This is the pattern with Hogg lately. He's found a second act as a guy who takes a real grievance, in this case anxiety over AI infrastructure gobbling up land and electricity near ordinary communities, and turns it into a tweet that sounds tough but doesn't survive five minutes of scrutiny. Wealthy suburbs generally have neither the grid infrastructure nor the water rights nor the zoning flexibility to host a hyperscale data center, and pretending otherwise isn't populism, it's cosplay.

The irony is that there's a genuine conversation to be had about where these facilities go and who bears the noise, the water use, the strain on local power bills. Communities from Georgia to Virginia are actually fighting these fights right now, with real stakes for real families. Hogg could have engaged with any of that. Instead he reached for a one-liner built for retweets, and the internet's fact-checking layer did what his own staff apparently didn't: it read the thing before he hit send.

What's telling is how little any of this seems to cost him. He'll be back next week with another confident-sounding claim about something he hasn't looked into, because the applause from his own side doesn't require him to be right. It just requires him to sound like he's fighting somebody.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.