El-Sayed finally apologizes for lamenting death of terrorist’s family in response to Michigan synagogue attack

Progressive policy ambitions meet practical realities as Americans weigh costs and consequences.

Source: New York Post
1 min read
Why This Matters

It took him seven months to say sorry, and only after Jewish Democrats in his own party forced the issue. That timeline tells you almost everything. A synagogue in Michigan gets attacked, and Abdul El-Sayed's first instinct is to pivot to lamenting the terrorist's family.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

El-Sayed finally apologizes for lamenting death of terrorist’s family in response to Michigan synagogue attack
Image via New York Post

Michigan Senate hopeful Dr. Abdul El-Sayed formally apologized to Jewish Democrats for weaving a jab at Israel in his response to an attack on a Michigan synagogue in March.

Original source:

Read at New York Post

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

It took him seven months to say sorry, and only after Jewish Democrats in his own party forced the issue. That timeline tells you almost everything. A synagogue in Michigan gets attacked, and Abdul El-Sayed's first instinct is to pivot to lamenting the terrorist's family. Not the congregants who had to live through it. Not the community that had to add security to a house of worship. He reached for Israel commentary in a moment that had nothing to do with Israel and everything to do with American Jews being targeted at home.

Apologies extracted under political pressure are worth noting for what they are. This wasn't a moment of reflection where El-Sayed reread his own words and winced. It's a Senate candidate doing arithmetic about Michigan's Jewish Democratic vote and realizing the math didn't work. That's not contrition, that's campaign management.

What's telling is how automatic the original instinct was. When something bad happens to a synagogue, you'd think the first reflex would be sympathy for the people who were actually attacked. Instead the reflex was to find the angle that criticized Israel anyway, as if every act of antisemitic violence needs to be run through a geopolitical filter before anyone's allowed to just feel bad for the victims.

Voters in Michigan get to decide whether a seven-month-late apology, delivered because donors and party officials made noise, tells them what they need to know. We think it does. You don't get credit for the apology you only gave once it became politically necessary..

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.