Florida Democrat distances herself from ‘extreme partisanship’ in new Trump-friendly House district

Progressive policy ambitions meet practical realities as Americans weigh costs and consequences.

Source: Washington Examiner
1 min read
Why This Matters

Kathy Castor has been in Congress since 2007, which means she voted for Nancy Pelosi as speaker something like eight times, backed the Green New Deal frameworks, and cheered on two impeachments. Now the district lines have shifted under her feet and suddenly she's "fed up" with extreme partisanship. Fed up with it now, that is.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Florida Democrat distances herself from ‘extreme partisanship’ in new Trump-friendly House district
Image via Washington Examiner

One of Florida’s most vulnerable incumbent Democrats is running a new ad distancing herself from “extreme partisanship,” a rhetorical appeal to the Right after her district was redrawn to favor Republicans.

Rep. Kathy Castor (D-FL), who has represented the Tampa area in Congress since 2007, tells voters in the 30-second commercial that she’s “fed up […]

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Kathy Castor has been in Congress since 2007, which means she voted for Nancy Pelosi as speaker something like eight times, backed the Green New Deal frameworks, and cheered on two impeachments. Now the district lines have shifted under her feet and suddenly she's "fed up" with extreme partisanship. Fed up with it now, that is. Not in 2019. Not in 2021. Now, when a more Republican Tampa electorate is staring back at her.

This is the oldest trick in the incumbent playbook and voters in Florida are not exactly known for falling for it twice. Redraw the map, soften the ad copy, talk like a moderate for sixty seconds, and hope nobody pulls the tape on the actual voting record. It's not a philosophy shift. It's a survival instinct, and there's nothing wrong with survival instincts in politics, but let's call it what it is instead of pretending she had some kind of awakening.

What makes this worth writing about isn't Castor specifically. It's how transparent the move is and how often it works anyway. Members of Congress spend years voting with leadership on party-line bills, then the second their seat gets competitive they start talking like independents who just wandered in off the street. Tampa voters have watched this Congresswoman for close to two decades. They know who shows up when the cameras aren't rolling and the vote is close.

If Castor genuinely believes partisanship has gotten out of hand, that's a fine thing to say. But belief shows up in votes cast over years, not in ad copy timed to a redistricting map. Voters in that district have every right to ask which version of her they're actually getting if she wins.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.