Gina Hinojosa releases new Flock-camera-focused campaign ad, attacking Abbott on privacy

Progressive policy ambitions meet practical realities as Americans weigh costs and consequences.

Source: Washington Examiner
1 min read
Why This Matters

Gina Hinojosa has found her opening line against Greg Abbott, and credit where it's due: she picked a real issue instead of another culture-war rerun. Texas has more Flock license-plate cameras than almost any state in the country, and the privacy questions around that aren't imaginary. Who has access to the data, how long it's kept, whether local police departments are quietly building location histories on ordinary drivers without a warrant in sight.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Gina Hinojosa releases new Flock-camera-focused campaign ad, attacking Abbott on privacy
Image via Washington Examiner

Texas state Rep. Gina Hinojosa released a new advertisement attacking Gov. Greg Abbott (R-TX) over the number of Flock cameras in Texas as she challenges him to be the next governor of the Lone Star State.

Hinojosa, the Democratic nominee for the gubernatorial ticket in Texas, has hit Abbott hard on divisive cross-party issues such […]

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Gina Hinojosa has found her opening line against Greg Abbott, and credit where it's due: she picked a real issue instead of another culture-war rerun. Texas has more Flock license-plate cameras than almost any state in the country, and the privacy questions around that aren't imaginary. Who has access to the data, how long it's kept, whether local police departments are quietly building location histories on ordinary drivers without a warrant in sight. Those are legitimate questions, and conservatives who actually believe in limited government should be asking them too, not waving them off because a Democrat got there first.

That said, an ad is not a policy, and "Abbott loves surveillance cameras" is a slogan, not an argument. If Hinojosa wants this to land as more than a thirty-second spot, she needs to say what she'd actually do: audit the contracts, set retention limits, require judicial sign-off for searches, something concrete. Texans have shown before that they'll punish politicians who let public safety tools turn into general-purpose tracking systems, but they also know the difference between a real reform pitch and a campaign ad chasing a news cycle.

Abbott's team will say the cameras help catch human traffickers and stolen vehicles, and sometimes they do. That's exactly why this fight matters and shouldn't be left to Democrats to define. If Republicans in Texas don't want to cede the privacy argument in a state built on distrust of unchecked government power, they'd do well to get ahead of it rather than just play defense on an ad they didn't like.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.