Mamdani and Curtis Sliwa team up on video and hold hands

Conservative principles face implementation challenges as policy meets political complexity.

Source: Washington Examiner
2 min read
Why This Matters

Curtis Sliwa held hands with a socialist on live TV, and the city didn't collapse. That may sound like the start of a joke, but Friday's flu shot photo-op between Sliwa and Zohran Mamdani, his rival from last year's mayoral race, is worth a little attention. **It was political theater with a purpose**, and that purpose is a lot less embarrassing than most of what passes for public service in New York.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Mamdani and Curtis Sliwa team up on video and hold hands
Image via Washington Examiner

New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani and his former political opponent, Republican Curtis Sliwa, sat side by side on Friday as they each received their annual flu shots. The two 2025 New York mayoral candidates held hands for a public health-related photo-op on Friday, about one year after they faced off in debates and on the ballot.

When Sliwa joked with the doctor giving the flu shots that the result could be “embarrassing,” adding “I’m supposed to be a tough guy,” Mamdani offered to hold the Republican’s hand. Amazon sending locals $1 billion after Trump tells Big Tech to ‘make communities happy’ about data centers Putin ignores two realities with Kaliningrad nuclear threats Somali former aide to Minneapolis mayor sentenced in Feeding Our Future fraud case “What happens if I faint?” Sliwa asked Mamdani.

Sliwa made several jokes throughout the press opportunity, as Mamdani and the Republican politician encouraged New Yorkers to get their flu shots during flu season. “You know he got more votes than me, he’s more popular than me,” Sliwa said , per ABC7. “But you don’t have bigger muscles!” Sliwa, the founder of a nonprofit crime-fighting group called the Guardian Angels, also poked fun at how many times he has personally survived being shot by bullets, which, per the outlet, happened five times in the span of just one month in 1992. “I know about getting shot,” Sliwa said.

MAMDANI UNVEILS BLUEPRINT TO COMBAT ANTISEMITISM IN NEW YORK CITY Mamdani, a socialist, defeated both Sliwa and embattled former Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo to win his ticket to Gracie Mansion in 2025.

Mamdani received 50.8% of the vote, while Cuomo garnered 41.3, and Sliwa garnered 7%.

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Curtis Sliwa held hands with a socialist on live TV, and the city didn't collapse. That may sound like the start of a joke, but Friday's flu shot photo-op between Sliwa and Zohran Mamdani, his rival from last year's mayoral race, is worth a little attention. It was political theater with a purpose, and that purpose is a lot less embarrassing than most of what passes for public service in New York.

Remember, these two spent months trading attacks in debates and mailers. Sliwa called Mamdani a far-left extremist with no plan for the city, and Mamdani said Sliwa was a right-wing stuntman. And on Friday they sat in chairs next to each other, rolled up sleeves, and did what a couple of grown-ups do about flu season. They set the bitterness aside for the price of a needle prick. That is not the same as endorsing each other's policies, and nobody should pretend otherwise. Mamdani still wants rent control and defunded police rhetoric, and Sliwa still wants to clean up the streets.

But there is something genuinely refreshing about watching two men who know voters didn't pick either of them actually behave like neighbors instead of enemies. New York politics is a contact sport, and the temptation is always to treat your opponent as a disease. On Friday, the only virus in the room was the flu. A little civility goes a long way, and it is especially welcome from a Republican like Sliwa, who could have easily skipped the event and let the cameras have Mamdani alone.

Sure, it was a photo-op. Both men got something out of it. But so did the public, which is more than we can say for most staged moments in politics. We need more of this, not less. Not because we all need warm feelings, but because political fights work better when the people involved remember they share a city, a planet, and a common interest in not getting sick. Sliwa got a shot in the arm. New York got a reminder that the other side is not the plague.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.