Trump’s Upstate NY trip to help Blakeman is play to save

Conservative principles face implementation challenges as policy meets political complexity.

Source: New York Post
4 min read
Why This Matters

President Trump’s trip to upstate New York isn’t about a photo op. It’s a rescue mission for Bruce Blakeman, and more importantly, a defensive play to keep two House seats from turning blue. The national media will paint this as a vanity project for a former president, but they’re missing the quiet math happening in the suburbs.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Trump’s Upstate NY trip to help Blakeman is play to save
Image via New York Post

President Trump’s trip to upstate New York next week is a bid to help his pal Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman — but also to help prevent Republican House seats from slipping away. Trump is set to campaign with Republican gubernatorial candidate Blakeman in Syracuse on Oct. 9, as the GOP looks to juice turnout in a state where several House races are suddenly competitive.

Blakeman, who has been attacking Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul on tax cuts and energy costs, has been keeping his own race competitive. But he also has an effect on candidates down the ticket, and Trump needs to try to make sure Republicans are enthusiastic enough to show up and vote. “In ‘22, New York state determined the House majority.

And in 2026, New York could determine it again,” said one Republican operative. Republicans point to former Rep. Lee Zeldin’s (R-NY) 2022 campaign for governor, arguing that his bid helped drive Republican turnout across the state even though he ultimately lost to Hochul, 53%-47%.

The challenge for Trump is that his ability to fire up Republicans comes with a potential downside: He is deeply unpopular with many New York Democrats who are gunning to vote. “I think it’s going to cut both ways.

On the one hand, Trump’s negatives in New York are very deep. People are very emotional — the ones that don’t like Trump really don’t like him,” said Grant Reeher, a political science professor at Syracuse University’s Maxwell School of Citizenship.

But he can also help fill the Republican enthusiasm gap, said Reeher: “Certainly one thing the guy is good at is getting people ramped up. On balance it may be something that could help the Republican candidates.” Rep.

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) made her own political trip upstate last week, with a plan to set up campaign infrastructure to turn out low propensity voters. Republican Anthony Constantino, a candidate in New York’s 21st Congressional District, is among those GOP candidates who have most enthusiastically hugged Trump.

He even put a Trump sign on the roof of his sticker business. Constantino announced Thursday that he was loaning another $4 million to his campaign as he tries to keep retiring Rep. Elise Stefanik’s seat in GOP hands, bringing his total personal loans to $16 million.

His race is drawing unusual attention in the North Country, where the district has traditionally been safely Republican. His Democratic opponent, Blake Gendebien, said his campaign raised $2 million in the last fundraising quarter.

Constantino might need to spend the money he’s loaned, thanks to signs of a “blue wave” that could take down Republican candidates due to high gas prices and the unpopular trade war with Canada. “That district should not be competitive,” said Erin Covey of the Cook Political Report.

Trump won it by 21 percentage points in 2024, but Covey pointed to Constantino’s polarizing image and the trade war’s particular impact on the region as factors making the race more competitive. And then there’s Rep.

Mike Lawler (R-NY), whose Hudson Valley seat is one of the country’s most closely watched House battlegrounds. Lawler’s race against Democrat Cait Conley is currently razor close: An Emerson College poll released Wednesday had Conley ahead 48%-46%, while a new internal Lawler poll showed the Republican ahead 50%-47% — both within the respective margins of error. “That’s a guy that’s going to be really worried about the turnout issue,” said Reeher.

Trump’s trip to Syracuse could also help Republican Kailee Buller, a former top aide to Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins. She is trying to topple Rep. John Mannion (D-NY), who won his last race with 55% of the vote.

Original source:

Read at New York Post

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

President Trump’s trip to upstate New York isn’t about a photo op. It’s a rescue mission for Bruce Blakeman, and more importantly, a defensive play to keep two House seats from turning blue. The national media will paint this as a vanity project for a former president, but they’re missing the quiet math happening in the suburbs. If the GOP loses these districts, it won’t be because of anything Trump said on stage—it’ll be because they waited too long to play offense in a state they usually write off.

This is what a smart campaign looks like in 2025. You don’t just defend your incumbents; you make the other side spend money where they thought they were safe. Blakeman is a solid county executive who has taken his lumps over the migrant crisis spiraling in New York City’s shadow, and Trump showing up gives him the megaphone he needs to nationalize a local problem. It also reminds suburban voters that the GOP is the party actually pushing back on the sanctuary policies and soft-on-crime rhetoric bleeding out of Albany and City Hall.

The real headline is that New York is no longer a write-off for Republicans. The congestion pricing debacle and the migrant spending have alienated working-class voters, including the union households that used to be reliable Democrats. Trump understands that these are the voters who decide control of the House, and he’s going to shake their hands personally. That’s the difference between the GOP and a Democratic machine that takes its base for granted. We say it’s a smart move because it is—it forces the left to defend indefensible policies in front of an audience that is fed up with paying for them.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.