Appeals court oks Trump-backed Missouri congressional map, but

Constitutional questions test judicial philosophy as Americans debate the role of unelected judges.

Source: Washington Times
1 min read
Why This Matters

the congressional map is lawful. That should have been the end of it. Instead, the Supreme Court's earlier order means these districts won't be used in November, leaving the state to scramble under lines that a federal appeals court has now said are fine.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Appeals court oks Trump-backed Missouri congressional map, but
Image via Washington Times

A long-running legal fight over Missouri's congressional map took another turn Monday when a federal appeals panel ruled in favor of new districts backed by President Donald Trump, even though the U.S.

Supreme Court has blocked those districts from being used in the November election.

Original source:

Read at Washington Times

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

the congressional map is lawful. That should have been the end of it. Instead, the Supreme Court's earlier order means these districts won't be used in November, leaving the state to scramble under lines that a federal appeals court has now said are fine. That's a strange way to run an election.

The map in question was backed by President Trump and passed by the Republican legislature. Democrats sued, claiming racial gerrymander, but the appeals court wasn't buying it. It ruled that the challengers failed to prove their case. The map isn't discriminatory. It's just not convenient for Democrats. That distinction seems lost on the left, which would rather keep litigating than accept a legitimate result.

We're not going to pretend the Supreme Court's decision is easy to explain. There are procedural rules about when to intervene, and the Court chose to hold off for now. But the practical effect is a mess: a map cleared on the merits, and then shelved for the election anyway. Missouri deserves better than this legal limbo. The appeals court did its job. Now it's time to let the state use its lawful map, or admit the real objection is political.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.