Graham Platner’s collapse casts shadow over Abdul el Sayed in Michigan Democratic Senate primary

Progressive policy ambitions meet practical realities as Americans weigh costs and consequences.

Source: Washington Examiner
1 min read
Why This Matters

Graham Platner's flameout in Maine should have been a two-week story about one guy's bad tattoos and worse Reddit history. Instead it's turning into a full-blown identity crisis for Democratic primary voters everywhere, and now Abdul el Sayed in Michigan is getting dragged into a debate that isn't really about him at all. That's what happens when a party builds its whole brand around "authenticity" and then discovers the authentic version of some candidates includes a swastika tattoo and posts nobody bothered to check before the cameras showed up.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Graham Platner’s collapse casts shadow over Abdul el Sayed in Michigan Democratic Senate primary
Image via Washington Examiner

Graham Platner’s spectacular collapse in Maine is reverberating through Democratic politics well beyond one Senate race, prompting a fresh debate over how the party vets insurgent candidates and whether Michigan’s closely watched Senate primary has become the next test of those lessons.

With just weeks remaining before Democrats choose a nominee to replace retiring Sen. […]

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Graham Platner's flameout in Maine should have been a two-week story about one guy's bad tattoos and worse Reddit history. Instead it's turning into a full-blown identity crisis for Democratic primary voters everywhere, and now Abdul el Sayed in Michigan is getting dragged into a debate that isn't really about him at all. That's what happens when a party builds its whole brand around "authenticity" and then discovers the authentic version of some candidates includes a swastika tattoo and posts nobody bothered to check before the cameras showed up.

The funny part is watching Democratic strategists rediscover the concept of vetting like it's some ancient lost technology. For years the energy on the left has rewarded the rawest, most online, most "unfiltered" candidates because that's what plays well with the base and the donor class chasing the next Fetterman. Platner was supposed to be that guy. Now every insurgent candidate with a social media footprint is getting a retroactive background check, and el Sayed, who has his own history of combative online statements and progressive positions that don't exactly poll well in Michigan, is a convenient stand-in for the party's anxiety.

None of this is our problem to solve, but it's worth noting how thin the vetting apparatus apparently was in the first place. A national party spending hundreds of millions on Senate races couldn't manage basic opposition research on its own candidates before they became front-runners. That's not a Platner problem or an el Sayed problem. That's a party that outsourced discipline to vibes and is now paying for it primary by primary.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.