Is the nonsocialist Democratic establishment fooling itself?

Progressive policy ambitions meet practical realities as Americans weigh costs and consequences.

Source: Washington Examiner
1 min read
Why This Matters

The Michigan Senate primary is a nice little case study in Democratic wishful thinking. Haley Stevens posts a good poll number against Abdul el Sayed, Whitmer's old rival gets a fresh look, and suddenly the party's moderate wing is telling itself the socialist wave broke on the shore. Graham Platner flames out in Maine, and the establishment reads that as proof the fever's passing rather than as one bad candidate having a bad month.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Is the nonsocialist Democratic establishment fooling itself?
Image via Washington Examiner

It looked like the tide was turning in the Democratic primary for Senate in Michigan. Fresh off socialist Graham Platner’s implosion in Maine, a poll came out showing Rep. Haley Stevens (D-MI) shellacking progressive Abdul el Sayed among black and working-class voters.

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (D-MI), who had beaten el Sayed in the 2018 gubernatorial […]

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

The Michigan Senate primary is a nice little case study in Democratic wishful thinking. Haley Stevens posts a good poll number against Abdul el Sayed, Whitmer's old rival gets a fresh look, and suddenly the party's moderate wing is telling itself the socialist wave broke on the shore. Graham Platner flames out in Maine, and the establishment reads that as proof the fever's passing rather than as one bad candidate having a bad month.

That's the tell. Democrats keep treating their socialist problem as a candidate quality issue instead of an ideas issue. El Sayed isn't struggling because he can't debate or because his opposition research file is thin. He's running on a message that a big chunk of the base actually wants, even if it scares the donors and the consultants writing these columns about "electability." Stevens leading among black and working-class voters in one poll is real, but it's also the exact coalition Democrats have been hemorrhaging for a decade, and winning them back for one cycle in a primary doesn't mean the bleeding stopped.

We've watched this movie before. The moderate wing convinces itself the party has learned its lesson, nominates someone safe, and then acts shocked when the socialist energy either sits home in November or finds another vehicle two years later. If Stevens wins Michigan, fine, but the underlying fight in that party isn't going away because one poll came out favorable. Somebody over there needs to ask why a self-described socialist keeps coming this close to a Senate nomination in a state Democrats used to think they owned outright.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.