Jack Smith team read messages between Trump officials, dozens of lawmakers of both parties: ‘Ran roughshod over the Constitution’

Conservative principles face implementation challenges as policy meets political complexity.

Source: New York Post
1 min read
Why This Matters

Forty-four members of Congress, from both parties, had their private text messages pulled by a federal prosecutor's team investigating the sitting president's predecessor. Sit with that for a second. This wasn't some rogue staffer's phone.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Jack Smith team read messages between Trump officials, dozens of lawmakers of both parties: ‘Ran roughshod over the Constitution’
Image via New York Post

Forty-four members of Congress had their text messages viewed by former special counsel Jack Smith's team amid a probe into President Trump, in an move that Republicans say "ran roughshod over the Constitution."

Original source:

Read at New York Post

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Forty-four members of Congress, from both parties, had their private text messages pulled by a federal prosecutor's team investigating the sitting president's predecessor. Sit with that for a second. This wasn't some rogue staffer's phone. These were sitting lawmakers, people with their own constitutional standing, having their communications swept up in a probe that was already controversial before this detail surfaced.

The bipartisan part matters here, and it's worth not glossing over. This isn't a story where only Trump allies got caught in the net. Democrats' messages were reportedly read too, which tells you this wasn't a targeted, surgical legal maneuver so much as a wide net thrown by a team that apparently didn't think much about where it landed. That should bother people regardless of who they voted for last November.

Prosecutors have broad power to build a case, but Congress isn't supposed to be an afterthought in that process. When investigators are reading messages between elected officials without those officials even knowing it happened until much later, something has gone wrong with the guardrails that are supposed to keep executive branch investigators from treating the legislative branch like just another target. Republicans calling this an assault on constitutional boundaries aren't being dramatic. They're describing what happened.

The Smith investigation was always going to be scrutinized to death, fairly or not, because of who it targeted. But this detail stands on its own. If federal investigators can read a member of Congress's texts as a matter of course during a politically charged probe, that's not a partisan complaint. That's a warning about how power gets used when nobody's watching the watchers.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.