NY GOP candidate threatens to sue pollster after shock survey has him trailing Dem opponent for Rep. Stefanik’s seat

Progressive policy ambitions meet practical realities as Americans weigh costs and consequences.

Source: New York Post
1 min read
Why This Matters

If you don't like a poll, the normal move is to commission your own, point out the sample size, or just ignore it and keep knocking on doors. Threatening to sue the pollster is a different animal entirely, and it tells you something about where Anthony Constantino's head is at right now. This is Elise Stefanik's old seat, a district Republicans should be able to hold in their sleep, and a candidate lashing out at the messenger instead of the numbers is not exactly a confidence builder for the base he needs to turn out.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

NY GOP candidate threatens to sue pollster after shock survey has him trailing Dem opponent for Rep. Stefanik’s seat
Image via New York Post

A new shock poll has Republican businessman Anthony Constantino trailing his Democratic opponent in his bid to succeed retiring Rep. Elise Stefanik in a heavily Republican district.

Original source:

Read at New York Post

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

If you don't like a poll, the normal move is to commission your own, point out the sample size, or just ignore it and keep knocking on doors. Threatening to sue the pollster is a different animal entirely, and it tells you something about where Anthony Constantino's head is at right now. This is Elise Stefanik's old seat, a district Republicans should be able to hold in their sleep, and a candidate lashing out at the messenger instead of the numbers is not exactly a confidence builder for the base he needs to turn out.

Polls get things wrong plenty. Everybody remembers 2016 and 2020 and the industry's uneven track record since. But there's a difference between skepticism and legal threats aimed at shutting down bad news. One is healthy distrust of an imperfect science. The other looks like a candidate trying to intimidate anyone who says something he doesn't want voters to hear, which is a strange look for someone asking those same voters to trust him with their vote.

New York Republicans worked hard to build the kind of momentum that flipped seats and made Stefanik a national figure. That doesn't happen by treating a rough survey like a courtroom matter. If Constantino thinks the methodology is junk, say so and show your work. Suing your way out of an uncomfortable headline just hands the Democrats a storyline for free, and in a race this winnable, that's the last gift Republicans should be handing over.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.