Opinion: Leaders should police their own parties

Public safety requires backing law enforcement while progressive policies face results-based scrutiny.

Source: The Enterprise News
1 min read
Why This Matters

they moved fast. A couple of county-level candidates got caught with ugly, racially charged posts, and the state party was out the door with public condemnations before the story had time to bake. That’s the right instinct, and it’s a shame it took a scandal to force the issue.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Opinion: Leaders should police their own parties
Image via The Enterprise News

North Carolina Democrats and Texas Republicans disavowed candidates over offensive posts, prompting an argument that party leaders should police extremism within their own ranks.

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

they moved fast. A couple of county-level candidates got caught with ugly, racially charged posts, and the state party was out the door with public condemnations before the story had time to bake. That’s the right instinct, and it’s a shame it took a scandal to force the issue. Over in Texas, the GOP took a little longer to wrangle its own fringe figures, but they got there eventually. Both parties are claiming the moral high ground, and both are pretending this is harder than it actually is.

Here’s the uncomfortable truth nobody in leadership wants to say out loud: you don’t need a purity test to spot a bigot. You just need to look at the screen. The posts that got these candidates in trouble weren't subtle dog whistles. They were the kind of stuff that makes a reasonable person wince and move on. The argument that leaders should police their own ranks is fine as far as it goes, but it assumes the parties are the ones responsible for instilling basic decency. That’s giving them too much credit. The real pressure valve is the primary process. The voters who show up in March and June are the first line of defense, and they should not need a press release from party headquarters to tell them what’s disqualifying.

The left wants to use this moment to demand Republicans go further, to purge anyone who ever shared a meme from a sketchy account. We’re not in the business of giving them that satisfaction. There’s a difference between policing actual hateful behavior and the left’s preferred sport of ideological witch-hunting. But we can admit when the GOP’s cleanup crew works slower than it should. A state party cutting out its own cancer is not a sign of weakness, it’s a sign of governance. The Texas Republicans who finally pulled the trigger know this, and they’re better off for it.

At the end of the day, both parties are going to disappoint their base with these calls. That’s the nature of leadership. But the public spectacle of watching Democrats pretend they’ve never had a racist in their coalition is rich. We remember their history, and we’re not impressed by their sudden bout of amnesia. The point isn't to win a debate on cable news. It's to keep the worst instincts from finding a home in either party. So go ahead, police your own. But don’t expect a medal for doing the bare minimum, and don’t get to lecture us when the GOP’s house cleaning isn’t on your schedule.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.