Senate confirms Todd Blanche as Trump’s attorney general in 50-49 vote

Progressive policy ambitions meet practical realities as Americans weigh costs and consequences.

Source: New York Post
1 min read
Why This Matters

A 50-49 vote for an attorney general nominee tells you something is off, and not necessarily about the nominee. This is the man's job now, and he got there on the thinnest possible margin, with Murkowski and Collins peeling off in what has become their standard two-woman protest caucus against anything Trump-adjacent. At some point that predictability stops looking like independence and starts looking like a script.

New Republican Times Editorial Board

Senate confirms Todd Blanche as Trump’s attorney general in 50-49 vote
Image via New York Post

Two Republicans, Sens. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) and Susan Collins (R-Maine), voted with all Democrats against his confirmation.

Original source:

Read at New York Post

How We See It

New Republican Times Editorial Board

A 50-49 vote for an attorney general nominee tells you something is off, and not necessarily about the nominee. This is the man's job now, and he got there on the thinnest possible margin, with Murkowski and Collins peeling off in what has become their standard two-woman protest caucus against anything Trump-adjacent. At some point that predictability stops looking like independence and starts looking like a script.

That said, a party that can only confirm its own president's top law enforcement officer by one vote has a math problem, not just a messaging problem. Fifty is fifty. There's no cushion left for the next fight, the next nominee, the next piece of legislation that needs Republican unity to survive. Blanche now runs the Justice Department having watched two members of his own party's caucus vote no in a moment when the administration needed a show of strength, not a nail-biter.

None of this is really about Blanche's qualifications, which barely got mentioned in the coverage. It's about the same two senators doing the same thing they always do, and a caucus that keeps needing every single other vote to compensate for it. That's not a sustainable way to run a Senate majority, and eventually something more consequential than an AG confirmation is going to come down to the wire and not make it.

Commentary written with AI assistance by the New Republican Times Editorial Board.